Speaking of “vexatious requestors”

Yesterday, the Philadelphia Inquirer ran a front-page story, Public service vs. public nuisance about the outraged reaction of government officials in Pennsylvania to a contest the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association announced several weeks ago.

That contest encourages citizens throughout Pennsylvania to file an open records request with a city or county government, or a public school district, and then report back on their findings.

Among others, the County Commissioners Association of Pennsylvania reacted angrily to the contest, calling it “unconscionable” and implying that the contest would clog up the work calendars of already-overworked public officials.

I disagree. The contest sponsored by the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association, in my view, is an upgraded, pro-citizen version of the time-honored FOIA audit, in which newspapers and professional journalists send out reporters to see how agencies do at responding to the requests.

One such audit in Colorado last year sponsored by the Colorado Press Association and the Denver Post discovered that “Public” is relative.

Ed Otte, executive director of the Colorado Press Association, said that the results showed that:

…obtaining records can be an intimidating and disheartening process for members of the public.

When the Better Government Association in Illinois conducted a FOIA audit in 2006, they learned that when ordinary citizens asked Illinois agencies for records, they were turned away 62% of the time.

I think it’s great that the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association is encouraging regular folks to get out there and file open records requests.

The advantages:

  • It’s like teaching someone to fish–they learn the skills needed to keep on top of things themselves, rather than having to rely on professional reporters. Investigative journalism is expensive, and journalists with these skills are being laid off every day. Citizen watchdogs can take up a bit of the slack, but only if they’re encouraged to learn the skills.
  • The only way you can find out how government agencies respond to open records requests from regular folks (as opposed to people they know to be reporters or investigators) is to have regular folks file open records requests.
  • HT: Pass Open Records.


    2 responses to “Speaking of “vexatious requestors”

    1. Pingback: The last time a FOI audit was conducted in Pennsylvania, it wasn’t too great « State Sunshine and Open Records

    2. Pingback: Governors who don’t like open records…It’s turning into a series. « State Sunshine and Open Records

    Leave a Reply

    Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

    WordPress.com Logo

    You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

    Google+ photo

    You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

    Twitter picture

    You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

    Facebook photo

    You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


    Connecting to %s